Correction and update, October 21, 2026: The earlier article described a February 2025 retrial as a future event and did not report the subsequent verdict and sentence. It has been revised to distinguish the federal decisions from the later state proceedings and to remove unsupported predictions and access-to-counsel claims.
Eddie Williams won federal relief from his original conviction, but that was not the end of the case. A new jury convicted him in 2025, and he received another life sentence.
The federal proceedings
Williams was convicted in Pennsylvania in 2015 in a prosecution arising from the killing of Marcus Ortiz and the shooting of another person. The federal district court granted habeas relief in May 2022. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed that decision on August 13, 2024.
The appellate opinion addresses the trial judge’s reading of charges associated with a non-testifying codefendant’s guilty plea. That reading identified Williams as a participant. The court analyzed the Confrontation Clause and related ineffective-assistance claim, rather than deciding that Williams was factually innocent.
What happened at the new trial
Daily Voice reported that a Lebanon County jury convicted Williams again in June 2025. Citing the district attorney’s office, it reported that he was sentenced on August 13, 2025, to life without parole plus 25 years.
That later reporting supersedes the earlier description on this site of an upcoming retrial. The sources below document different stages: the federal opinion explains why the first proceedings could not stand, while the news report describes the outcome of the subsequent prosecution.
What readers should distinguish
Winning relief from a conviction is not the same as an acquittal or the dismissal of every charge. An accurate case history needs to follow what happened after the reversal, even when that outcome complicates the original story.
When checking an article about a retrial, compare the date of the appellate decision with the dates of any later verdict and sentencing. An old scheduling announcement should not be presented as a current case status.
Sources
- Third Circuit opinion, August 13, 2024, Nos. 22-2053 and 22-2076.
- Daily Voice: June 2025 reconviction and August 2025 sentencing.
To provide a later decision or identify an error, use our corrections process.
